
CBS's venture into MMA (mixed martial arts) by showcasing EliteXC fights has temporarily brought the world of combat sports to the forefront of public discussion. It seems that over the course of the weekend and yesterday that the discussion has boiled down to three questions:
1. Is MMA too violent for network (free) TV?
2. Did the EliteXC broadcast succeed in pulling in new fans to the world of MMA?
3. How does EliteXC measure up to the competition, especially the better known UFC?
Is MMA too violent for network (free) TV?
In my mind the first question is highly debateable for only one reason: Blood. There is no other sport where an athlete can begin bleeding and no time-out is called, no trainer runs into the ring, and the referees wear surgical gloves. To be fair, in the MMA fights that I have viewed the referees will stop the action if the blood is a direct threat to the fighters well being (ie bleeding into the eyes), but if the blood is only poses a long night to the poor guy that cleans the ring floor - game on.
If you move past the topic of blood, there is not argument. Network television shows NHL games, in-which fights occur. After any stoppage or puck drop there is a chance that two guys will drop gloves grab eachothers jerseys and begin throwing over-hand rights. Plus, let's not kid ourselves, America loves a good hit - as long as no one is permanently injured. While an MMA fighters face may look like it has been rubbed on a cheese grater following 3 five minute rounds, I have yet to see a fight where one of the fighters has sustained a permanent injury. Dana White, President of the UFC, was on ESPN to debate the effect of the EliteXC broadcast on MMA and was doing well until he made an ill comparison. MMA vs NFL. While there may be an argument to be had here, you don't take on the king. A lot of NFL fans heard those comments and I guarantee were quick to jump to their league's defense and damn MMA.
2. Did the EliteXC broadcast succeed in bringing new fans to MMA?
Maybe. The best fight of the night was stopped due to an inadvertant eye poke, the headliner came on waaay after broadcast time, and Kimbo Slice was not anywhere near dominate. The timing of the show was extremely sloppy leaving viewers in agonizingly long wait periods for the next fight to tee up. Plus, how long might the show have been had all of the fights gone to a decision? We would be watching Kimbo Slice's labored breathing instead of Sunday Morning and all of the Charles Osgood faithful would be up in arms!
Having said all of this, you cannot argue with the ratings. CBS was able to pull in millions of viewers in a demographic that advertisers slobber over. Does this translate to new fans of the sport? No one knows. EliteXC made the mistake of not putting their best foot forward. The announcers were Busch League at best (Gus Johnson was bad, but Frank Shamrock was dreadful) and the overall production did not cater to those who were already in the MMA fan base. If EliteXC can find some big-name fighter(s) to legitimize their league (I hear Tito is shopping) they clearly have a lot of folks accross the US curious. This question will be answered nearer the fall when EliteXC holds its next primetime event.
How does EliteXC measure up to the competition, especially the better known UFC?
Simple answer: No. Having the network deal with CBS gives EliteXC the potential to be something big, but in its current form it cannot compete the UFC - and maybe not the ever growing WEC (for those that saw the Pulver v. Faber bout on Sunday) which is also owned by Zuffa.
Kimbo Slice assisted Gary Shaw, President EliteXC, in marketing something that hadn't been done before by reaching out to the YouTube generation through a YouTube phenom. But where do they go now? They have some ok fighters in their bullpen but none have near the name recognition of those fighting in the UFC.
While the UFC is lightyears ahead of EliteXC currently, it has some issues of its own. The UFC has a lot going for it: The Ultimate Fighter is a highly successfull reality TV show on Spike, it has the best MMA bullpen currently, and has the best production value of any of the MMA companies. But, there are not without their own issues: Currently in a lawsuit with Randy Couture - who is not only one of the biggest names but also trains a lot of top tiered fighters, they have not been able to draw Fedor Emelianenko (arguably the top heavyweight in the world) which has played heavily into the Randy Couture suit, and Dana White is more well known than most of their title holders.
Currently eliteXC is a sideshow that is in need of somethings to get to the main stage, but they have managed to open a door for themselves with the CBS contract. They need to land a couple of big name fighters, because I doubt they have the cash to stay around long enough to develop their own superstar from scratch.